Richard’s Literary Byways: Fragment 31, by Sappho

About › Forums › Den of Writers › Blogs › Richard’s Literary Byways: Fragment 31, by Sappho

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #15510
    RichardB
    Participant

      Something a bit different this time: a voice speaking from the shadows of two-and-a-half millennia and more ago, in words so timeless and universal they might have been written yesterday.

      It was a couple of years ago that I stumbled across this piece on the Internet, and I don’t remember what led me to it. But I do have a vivid memory of my reaction to it, of the awed surprise and delight, that sense of a bullseye having been scored which is one of the hallmarks of a good poem.

      I knew little or nothing about Sappho beyond what nearly everybody who has heard of her knows: that she was an Ancient Greek poet (though I didn’t realise quite how ancient) who gave her own name, and that of the island on which she lived, Lesbos, to female homosexuality. Likewise, my acquaintance with Ancient Greek poetry was slight to non-existent, not much more than a passing familiarity with some of the better-known episodes from the Iliad and the Odyssey: legendary tales of high adventure and heroism. This was nothing like that at all. I had no idea that there was anything in the poetry of the Ancient Greeks so intensely personal and immediate, so thrumming with emotion. Anything that delivered such a visceral punch.

      Nor was I aware of what good company I was in. I didn’t know that these qualities are exactly what she is celebrated for, nor that the piece I had found, known as Fragment 31, has been her most admired work from ancient times right up to the present day.

      Sappho, who is thought to have lived around 630 to 570BC, is a tantalisingly shadowy figure. Even to those better informed than I, very little is known about her life, and at this distance in time it is impossible to disentangle legend from fact, so I don’t see much point in going into the details, such as they are. And very little of her writing survives: we have just one complete poem, the Ode to Aphrodite, plus an assortment of fragments of varying lengths, to a total of only about 650 lines. According to one theory the Christian church ordered her works to be destroyed for their immorality and sinfulness.

      What is certain is the very high reputation her writings had throughout ancient times. She was commonly referred to as ‘The Tenth Muse’ (in addition to the nine of legend) or ‘The Poetess,’ as Homer was ‘The Poet.’ Indeed, the reason this piece survives when so much else has been lost is that the unidentified author of a book of aesthetics and criticism called On the Sublime, writing six or seven hundred years after Sappho’s death, quoted it as an example of her brilliance and intensity.

      So what’s all the fuss about? What is this gem of poetry from the distant past?

      It is not much, only about a hundred words long, and the situation it depicts is simple. A man and a girl are sitting chatting – where is not stated – and the poem’s narrator, who is head-over-heels with the girl, is watching them. As is the way with the best poetry, Sappho manages to say much more than you might think this slight framework could carry.

      None of this will mean very much unless I quote the poem. And here, of course, we run up against a problem. There can be no definitive version in a language Sappho didn’t write in. There have been many translations over the years, varying quite widely in emphasis and freedom of interpretation, and since I have no knowledge of Ancient Greek, let alone the dialect form of it in which Sappho wrote, I am unable to say which of them is truest to the original. Rather than impose my own taste and judgement by picking on just one, I shall give a few examples, so you can see how they differ, catch the various nuances they bring to the poem, and come to your own verdict.

      I think the best place to start is the version quoted in the Wikipedia article about the poem. Its sober style, devoid of the flights of fancy that adorn some other efforts, plus the fact that it is set beside the original Greek and follows its layout, suggests to me that it is probably a fairly literal translation. It is unattributed: it may be the work of whoever wrote the article.

      That man seems to me to be equal to the gods
      who is sitting opposite you
      and hears you nearby
      speaking sweetly

      and laughing delightfully, which indeed
      makes my heart flutter in my breast;
      for when I look at you even for a short time,
      it is no longer possible for me to speak

      but it is as if my tongue is broken
      and immediately a subtle fire has run over my skin,
      I cannot see anything with my eyes,
      and my ears are buzzing

      a cold sweat comes over me, trembling
      seizes me all over, I am paler
      than grass, and I seem nearly
      to have died.

      Of course the danger in translating poetry literally is that the spark, that quality that lifts words from stodge into poetry, can get lost in the translation. Let’s see how some other translators have got on. The Wikipedia article on Sappho herself contains a different version, this one by Edward Storer:

      He seems like a god to me the man who is near you,
      Listening to your sweet voice and exquisite laughter
      That makes my heart so wildly beat in my breast.
      If I but see you for a moment, then all my words
      Leave me, my tongue is broken and a sudden fire
      Creeps through my blood. No longer can I see.
      My ears are full of noise. In all my body I
      Shudder and sweat. I am pale as the sun-scorched
      Grass. In my fury I seem like a dead woman,

      The following ones are a little more adventurous. First, by Willis Barnstone:

      To me he seems like a god
      as he sits facing you and
      hears you near as you speak
      softly and laugh

      in a sweet echo that jolts
      the heart in my ribs. For now
      as I look at you my voice is empty and

      can say nothing as my tongue
      cracks and slender fire is quick
      under my skin. My eyes are dead
      to light. My ears

      pound, and sweat pours over me.
      I convulse, greener than grass,
      and feel my mind slip as I
      go close to death.

      Or this one, by Chris Childers:

      He seems like the gods’ equal, that man, who
      ever he is, who takes his seat so close
      across from you, and listens raptly to
      your lilting voice

      and lovely laughter, which, as it wafts by,
      sets the heart in my ribcage fluttering;
      as soon as I glance at you a moment, I
      can’t say a thing,

      and my tongue stiffens into silence, thin
      flames underneath my skin prickle and spark,
      a rush of blood booms in my ears, and then
      my eyes go dark,

      and sweat pours coldly over me, and all
      my body shakes, suddenly sallower
      than summer grass, and death, I fear and feel,
      is very near.

      And finally (Phew!) this one, by Daniel Mendelsohn:

      He seems to me an equal of the gods—
      whoever gets to sit across from you
      and listen to the sound of your sweet speech
      so close to him,

      to your beguiling laughter: O it makes my
      panicked heart go fluttering in my chest,
      for the moment I catch sight of you there’s no
      speech left in me,

      but tongue gags—: all at once a faint
      fever courses down beneath the skin,
      eyes no longer capable of sight, a thrum-
      ming in the ears,

      and sweat drips down my body, and the shakes
      lay siege to me all over, and I’m greener
      than grass, I’m just a little short of dying,
      I seem to me.

      ‘Are you not amazed,’ the author of On the Sublime wrote nearly two thousand years ago, ‘at how she evokes soul, body, hearing, tongue, sight, skin, as though they were external and belonged to someone else? And how at one and the same moment she both freezes and burns, is irrational and sane, is terrified and nearly dead, so that we observe in her not a single emotion but a whole concourse of emotions? Such things do, of course, commonly happen to people in love. Sappho’s supreme excellence lies in the skill with which she selects the most striking and vehement circumstances of the passions and forges them into a coherent whole.’

      And me? Well, I suppose your response to the poem rather depends on how familiar you are with the sufferings of unrequited love. I’ll put my hand up to that (though not from recent experience, I should maybe add), and so I got the full force of it. Even more than that astonishingly, and famously, vivid portrayal of the physical symptoms of being in love, it was the poignancy of the situation that struck home. Straight away I got a mental picture of a pretty girl and a man of about the same age sitting in animated conversation at a table, maybe after a banquet or similar function, blithely unaware of the older woman sitting on her own some way off looking on with steadfast sadness and yearning. She is wondering if he has god-like powers, this lucky bastard, for she can’t understand how else he can possibly sit at his ease so close to this girl and hold a normal conversation with her, when even a glimpse of her reduces the woman to a tongue-tied, quivering wreck. The odds are that the girl is straight, and that the woman knows it, in which case she also knows that her passion is almost certainly utterly hopeless. All she can do is keep her distance and stare, nursing her pain.

      That’s just my take on it. Scholars have been arguing for centuries over points of interpretation (What is the situation? What is the relationship between the man and the girl? Between the girl and the narrator? What exactly are the narrator’s feelings – beyond the obvious! – as she watches them?), and it is forever impossible to know what was in Sappho’s mind when she wrote the poem, whether it is autobiographical or conjured from her imagination. But we’re talking about lyric poetry, not history, and so there are no facts to be right or wrong about. We are all free to take what we want from Sappho’s poem, and that’s what I took. Such heart-wrenching sadness, such a potent charge of emotion, and all in about a hundred words. Pretty good going, I’d say.

      #15517
      Athelstone
      Moderator

        Great blog, Richard. Sadly I have very little internet right now. Will get back asap. Also, yikes! One of the updates has broken my menus (at least in mobile mode).

        #15518
        Libby
        Participant

          I’m looking forward to reading this, Richard. I became more aware of Sappho when I read Selby Wynn Schwartz’s novel After Sappho, which I enjoyed a lot. Before that I’d hardly known who Sappho was.

          #15521
          RichardB
          Participant

            Rather annoyingly, shortly after posting this I came upon another translation. Annoyingly, because its publication on a page headed ‘The Center for Hellenic Studies,’ its juxtaposition with the Greek, and most of all the clumsiness of its English suggest to me that it is the closest to a word-for-word rendition of Sappho’s original that I’ve yet found. It’s by Gregory Nagy, and goes like this:

            He appears to me, that one, equal to the gods
            the man, who, facing you,
            is seated and, up close, that sweet voice of yours
            he listens to

            and how you laugh a laugh that brings desire. Why, it just
            makes my heart flutter within my breast.
            You see, the moment I look at you, right then, for me
            to make a sound at all won’t work any more.

            My tongue has a breakdown and a delicate
            – all of a sudden – fire rushes under my skin.
            With my eyes I see not a thing, and there is a roar
            my ears make.

            Sweat pours down me and a trembling
            seizes all of me; paler than grass
            am I, and a little short of death
            do I appear to me.

            It contains one interesting nuance that every other translation I’ve quoted misses. Others have rendered the girl’s laughter as ‘delightful,’ beguiling,’ ‘exquisite,’ ‘lovely,’ etc, but this version says it is ‘a laugh that brings desire.’ Now, I did find one effort that described it as ‘sexy,’ but I thought that was a bit over-the-top and dismissed it. But if this translation is as true as I think it is, then ‘sexy’ is exactly the right word. And that cranks the watching woman’s feelings up a notch or two.

            You can tell I’ve really got into this, can’t you?

            #15525
            Libby
            Participant

              I replied in a comments box earlier where it may get lost – so I’ve copied my comment here.

              ***

              Definitely good going, Richard. Thank you for this post.

              Of these various translations I prefer the ones with shorter lines. They feel more immediate, less worked. That seems to be the magic of Sappho’s lines – the way they leap almost three millennia with apparent simplicity to show that little has changed. It’s a cliche to say that, I know, but it’s the fact they manage this , with so little surrounding ‘stuff’ to get in the way, that gives me a jolt. And the eternal subject matter of course.

              The translations Selby Wynne Schwartz used when she was working on After Sappho are those by Anne Carson in If Not Winter: Fragments of Sappho. So there’s yet another translation ???? I haven’t read Carson’s book but an Amazon review of If Not Winter is an adjunct to the interesting background provided by Richard: https://www.amazon.co.uk/If-Not-Winter-Fragments-Sappho/dp/1844080811
              And basically the reviewer says Carson doesn’t try too hard with her translations.

              #15528
              RichardB
              Participant

                I’m glad you copied this, Libby, because you saved me the trouble. Your comments should definitely be an integral part of this thread. And I’m glad, too, that the poem seems to have had much the same effect on you as it had on me.

                There’s more, much more, than ‘yet another translation.’ There’s a page with over forty, ranging from Catullus’ Latin version through Sir Phillip Sidney, Byron and Tennyson (pretty dodgy version, that) up to the present day – including Anne Carson’s:

                He seems to me equal to the gods that man
                whoever he is who opposite you
                sits and listens close
                to your sweet speaking

                and lovely laughing — oh it
                puts the heart in my chest on wings
                for when I look at you, even a moment, no speaking
                is left in me

                no: tongue breaks and thin
                fire is racing under skin
                and in eyes no sight and drumming
                fills ears

                and cold sweat holds me and shaking
                grips me all, greener than grass
                I am and dead — or almost
                I seem to me.

                I was aware of this, but didn’t put it in the original blog because I didn’t like the way she leaves out all the possessive pronouns in the third stanza. What’s wrong with ‘my tongue’ or ‘my skin?’ Petty? Well, I’ve included it now.

                I agree about the translations. Simple is good. Paraphrasing is okay; adding stuff not in the original or leaving out stuff that is, is not okay. I’m not interested in what someone else thinks Sappho ought to have, or might have, written. I want to know what she actually wrote.

                It seems to me that that’s exactly what Gregory Nagy has tried to do in the translation I quoted in my last post, since he obviously hasn’t tried to convert it into ‘proper’ English. So I took it upon myself to try to do that, keeping as close to his translation as is compatible with fluency, and I came up with this:

                He appears to me the equal of the gods, that one,
                the man who’s sitting facing you,
                up close, listening to that sweet voice of yours,
                and to you laughing your sexy laugh.
                Oh, it sets my heart fluttering in my breast.
                You see, the moment I look at you, in that instant
                I lose all power of speech.
                My tongue seizes up and all of a sudden
                a delicate fire races under my skin.
                My eyes can’t see a thing,
                and there’s a roaring in my ears.
                I’m running with sweat and my whole body
                is seized by trembling;
                I’m paler than dry grass, and it seems to me
                I’m close to death.

                (‘Paler than grass,’ which is what Sappho appears to have written, doesn’t make a lot of sense to us, accustomed as we are to our bright green British grass. ‘Greener than grass,’ as many translators have opted for, doesn’t make much sense in the context of the poem, unless you assume it’s about jealousy, which I don’t believe is its main drift. And was jealousy even green to the Ancient Greeks? I believe she was thinking about sun-scorched Greek grass, and so I have reluctantly made an interpolation, inserting the word ‘dry.’)

                #15529
                Libby
                Participant

                  Thanks, Richard! This becomes quite compulsive doesn’t it, a new thread of literature (new to me anyway) to follow and think about.

                  I’m off now for a few days and will read your post fully when I return.

                Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.