-
Sandra replied to the topic Wip beginning… in the forum Critiques 7 years, 8 months ago
Raine, as you know, I’m a lazy, non-analytical reader, so you’re getting facile first impressions from me – and thanks for ‘stochastic’ – but I thought this a really enticing beginning, launching lots of characters, all of whom promised interest, tension and above averagely intelligent entertainment.
-
Elle replied to the topic Memories in the forum Critiques 7 years, 8 months ago
Brilliant, congratulations!
-
Daedalus replied to the topic Memories in the forum Critiques 7 years, 8 months ago
Brilliant, well done John. Please put a link in the Podium when it’s published? You’re on a bit of a roll, there
-
Squidge posted an update 7 years, 8 months ago
There’s another NIBSer in the Den!! Welcome, Adriana…
-
-
John S Alty replied to the topic Memories in the forum Critiques 7 years, 8 months ago
Thanks everyone who contributed. A name change from Florence to Felicity, to avoid confusion with a hurricane of that name, a couple more edits and it was picked up by Across The Margin. Should be out in the next week or so. Now titled Felicity’s First.
-
-
-
-
Philippa East replied to the topic Wip beginning… in the forum Critiques 7 years, 8 months ago
Oop – crossed with Jonathan.
-
Philippa East replied to the topic Wip beginning… in the forum Critiques 7 years, 8 months ago
okay, might be waffling on a bit here, but it’s sparked a load of thoughts.
In general I like the opening couple of paragraphs. It paints a strong and immediate picture of character and place.
You set up the omniscient narrator with the phrase highlighted in bold below.
“When the lights went out across Europe, Lina Stephenson did not notice at…[Read more] -
Jonathan replied to the topic Wip beginning… in the forum Critiques 7 years, 8 months ago
Ooh, hmm, okay, now this is challenging. To me, in the opening bits, there is definitely a disembodied voice that says things like “Let her have this moment.” or “Two more people now, to the north of Devendra Kapoor, both of whom he knew although Lina Stephenson did not, yet.”. That opening section is very cool. I like it.
However the voice…[Read more]
-
Philippa East replied to the topic Wip beginning… in the forum Critiques 7 years, 8 months ago
Hi Raine,
I love the sound of this story. A literary apocalyptic novel? YES PLEASE!
I definitely like the idea of having scenes from various characters’ lives, i.e. to have sections in different POVs. I think it serves the genre well because it creates an epic, global canvas for your story. Basically – how is the human race as a whole going to…[Read more]
-
Raine replied to the topic Wip beginning… in the forum Critiques 7 years, 8 months ago
Dammit autocorrect! I’d not spotted the domain thing. Gah.
But thank-you for the vote of confidence. I’ve been vacillating back and forth like you wouldn’t believe!
-
Daedalus replied to the topic Wip beginning… in the forum Critiques 7 years, 8 months ago
Personally I like it. The narrator-y bits make the transitions into a sort of PD slide. If you’re going to introduce a range of geographically dispersed characters in a short piece of text, this seems like a good way to do it. And I like the voice
‘This was a Sunday, the day it began was a Thursday’ – comma splice?
‘Domain’ – Demain? (French for…[Read more]
-
Alan Rain replied to the topic Identification – and how you can create it in your novel in the forum The Writers' Lifeboat 7 years, 8 months ago
Yes, good advice, and true. Thanks for posting.
-
Raine started the topic Wip beginning… in the forum Critiques 7 years, 8 months ago
I’ve tinkered with this about 600 times, and now can’t tell whether the narrator-type voice works for this. It doesn’t stay this ‘external’ beyond this first chapter, but it felt like the best way to tie all the characters and inciting moments together. But now I have doubts…Any thoughts v welcome. (1,500 words ish, but even just thoughts on the…[Read more]
-
-
- Load More
