Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
What a lot of clever things have been said on this thread! I have read through them all now and it’s all fascinating.
I love Dara Marks, @raine, and your summary is brilliant. I’m getting ready to do NaNoWriMo with book two now and I’m holding these ideas in my head (as opposed to an actual firm plan, which truly is beyond me at first draft stage). While Im not a planner – more a thinker on paper, as @emmad says, lots of scribbles and musings – I find the deep structure of story profoundly satisfying and utterly fascinating. It does seem to resonate with what it is to be human, psychologically. Some stories have that satisfying ‘clunk’ to them, while others seem to skim the surface. I’m still on a learning curve with all this but really think there’s SO much there at a very deep level.
Yes, I agree that stories that just ‘work’ do have something profound and innate that chimes with human psychology. All these books on arcs and structure attempt to pin that down. And I also think that you can do a lot with this knowledge, but equally a lot of it lurks at the subconscious level – which is when you find things bubbling up you’ve never planned. And I also feel strongly – for me anyway – that it’s so important to hold space for the subconscious to do just that. Which is why rigid pre planning doesn’t do it for me. I find out my themes and structure as I go and hack away to refine it in the edits. Not to say this is the best method, at all, but it seems to be how I work.
@philippaeast – what really interesting thoughts! This whole thread has got me pondering. You lot are fantastic.ps @raine I do know what you mean about the female appendage sort of titles, too. thought I have a liking for “The (x person) of (somewhere interesting)” even thought they’ve been a bit done lately
Ooh interesting list @raine. I also like the feel of The Girl and The Missing. And yes, I like the idea of exile too @alanr.
I sent a list of ideas to my agent before I left for India (below) and the one that jumped out for her was When Days Tilt – which I have to admit is one of my favourites, even though it’s a bit more aslant to the plot/themes of the book…be interested to hear anyone else’s reactions:
– Daughter of Time and Void
– Gold Time and Grey
– Two Cities and the Void
– When Days Tilt
– The Metropolis of Time
– Shadow City
– London and her Shadow
– Two Queens in Timepps I’d also be up for SloMoWriMo 🙂
I’m doing it. It nearly killed me last year and I’m still astonished that I actually completed it…but I found it really useful to just get the words on the page and not get hung up on plot details or side-tracked by research. Also the momentum led to some story surprises, in a good way. I’m using it to kick start book two so I’ll buddy up with anyone who’ll have me!
Ps I don’t think it matters what you write, or even if you don’t hit target – you’re still getting those words down…
AnGal sounds like dystopian specfic YA to me. Of the others the first and last have s more generic feel – they just give me a kids/YA vibe – while the other two hint more at speculative, maybe darker. All of them feel kids/YA I think.
You lot are fantastic! Thank you all so much for brainstorming for me 🙂
@seagreen and @janeshuff – I think you’re really onto something there with The Time Stealer/Snatcher’s… and using that to bundle the series together. Going to ponder that.
@jd73 that made me snort – Iron Maiden’s back catalogue 🙂 But I love them. And I’m leaning towards having London in the there somewhere, but still not sure. (and thanks for liking the sound of it!).What I’m finding hard is making it atmospheric without being ‘fantasy generic’ if you know what I mean. Really hard. But there’s some real gems in here and my synapses are firing!
‘Shadow’ keeps popping up, too. Hmmm.
Gah! Too many good suggestions! Off to ruminate. THANK YOU all @squidge @daedalus @seagreen @janeshuff @jd73 @philippaeast @alanr @bellam @tonylyttle @johnalty x
I keep coming back to the words enmeshing/unmeshing. For me that feels really evocative of family tendrils, the way the brain works (especially in cases of forming, breaking and reforming connections). – it makes me think of a web and a net and a loosening of patterns. Don’t know how you might use it but I love that word!
Enmeshing Seven / Unmeshing Seven
Seven Enmeshed /Seven Unmeshed
The Enmeshing / Unmeshing (also love Sea’s The Untangling)Not sure about any of those, just throwing things out there.
(Funnily enough, I’ve had exactly the same feedback from agent about my book title – I’m going to copy you and start a thread for help as I’m struggling too…:-) )
Pow to you, too @philippaeast!
@janeshuff – ah, the sweet sound of a scene being NAILED! That gives me shivers of satisfaction. Everything pulling together and resonating all over the place…can’t wait to read the rewrite 🙂
Richard, that is truly a shocking piece of writing – awful to read but really well done. Very powerful. It doesn’t feel gratuitous to me, awful as it is.
Jane, I think I know the scene you’re referring to 😉 Reading through this thread and going back to my own comments to you, the issue I had with it was that it felt as if you were avoiding the scene a little bit (I completely understand why) – compared to the rest of the wonderfully immersive writing, it was the one scene where I pulled out of the action, rather than being yanked even deeper in because of its power. I know the POV is unique but maybe you could play with the idea of a closer PD, or one that is disjointed and trauma coloured, so we don’t get a literal description of each blow but rather the effect of it on your MC. Perhaps the extreme trauma could push her closer than she has ever been to Elizabeth? Sort of mashing them together through trauma? Which would also work really well with your ending, actually. It could be a real turning point in self discovery and could also follow through into the escape scene, which also felt a little quick and easy to me. Just thinking on the page. You’ve had lots of great suggestions here, I have every confidence you’ll find your solution and I can’t wait to read the revision 🙂
September 18, 2018 at 7:10 pm in reply to: Receiving an email headed 'Offer of Representation'…. #1527@debi, you can get here via Writers Forum/Den of Writers/Podium. There are many winding roads in the Den and I’m still working them out myself! I’m also eagerly awaiting such a link (OMG CAN YOU IMAGINE??) and you will definitely know about it the minute (if/when) it happens…
@skylark I’m already leaning on my agent with questions and it’s SO GOOD letting go of that pressure to make all the decisions on your own…Skylark, I wasn’t there to hear you speak, but felt that I was after reading your blog – you’ve obviously inspired so many and there is so much genuine delight at your success. Congratulations and well done you, and I’m so happy that this is happening for you 🙂 I have only read Jessica’s story in Stories For Homes – where it really stood out for me, even back then – and I know I have a rare treat in store when I get to Home.
September 15, 2018 at 2:31 am in reply to: Receiving an email headed 'Offer of Representation'…. #1375Thanks all 🙂
@vandemal, yes it IS Ava, though she’s changed a bit since you last saw her and is now gallivanting through Burlington Arcade in 1858…but she’s the same Ava at heart. And thank you! 🙂That’s what I thought, @skylark, so it’s good to hear your experience. There is benefit at the business end, of course, but it’s also having someone in your corner who knows the ever-changing mazeways of publishing, isn’t it? It just feels so good to have a savvy partner in this writing biz, which is so solitary otherwise. And thank you!
WHOOP! that’s so exciting. Congratulations CJ.
Great idea, Mad, and some good ones here.
Hmm. Steven King said something similar to Raine’s ‘Write the first draft for yourself, edit for your readers’ with his ‘Write the first draft with the door closed, the second draft with the door open’ which has always stuck with me.
I also found the discipline of writing something, anything, for at least 10 minutes a day a good one for a while there. It keeps writing top of mind and does seem to exercise that writing muscle so that it becomes stronger and more nimble. More responsive to the day. I found I was looking at things with a more writerly viewpoint.
One I love – taking home a face each day. I can’t remember where I first saw this one, but its basically choosing a face to study (surreptitiously!) when you’re out and about, and then getting home and writing as full a description as you can from memory. You can then take it to a story stage, surmising who this person is, what their story might be. This could also apply to a moment, a conversation, a sighting, whatever.
September 12, 2018 at 3:52 am in reply to: Receiving an email headed 'Offer of Representation'…. #1068Thanks @debi! I am indebted to you and Emma for getting me this stage 🙂 I’m so excited…I’m watching emails between my agent and the Penguin Random House editor fly, saying such nice things, and I’m having to pinch myself 🙂
@bric – thank you love! You played a big part with your beta magnificence, too 🙂And thank you everyone, for all the good wishes. It means a lot. xx
September 11, 2018 at 9:20 pm in reply to: Receiving an email headed 'Offer of Representation'…. #1059You’re all brilliant. Thank you so much for your really heartwarming comments. I keep reading them with (another) stupid grin on my face.
And I have been VERY remiss in not singling out two members of the previous Cloud for special thanks – @debi and Emma Darwin, who run the phenomenally excellent Self Editing your Novel course – which first brought me to the Cloud, in fact, and where I met Random High Priestess @jillybean. Without them, this book would simply not be anywhere near where it is. Their toolbox still helps me every day 🙂
I can only blame the giddy blur I was in all day yesterday…
September 11, 2018 at 12:10 pm in reply to: Receiving an email headed 'Offer of Representation'…. #1010Thank you all so much. I’m always blown away by the generosity of other writers here 🙂
Jules – you are the one person to have followed Ava all the way through! Thank you again for all your help along the way xx
September 11, 2018 at 11:32 am in reply to: Receiving an email headed 'Offer of Representation'…. #996And Squidge!! Thank you 🙂 so exciting!
September 11, 2018 at 11:31 am in reply to: Receiving an email headed 'Offer of Representation'…. #995Thanks so much for those generous comments, Sandra and Daeds 🙂
September 11, 2018 at 11:11 am in reply to: Flash Fiction Win – posted in the right place now, I hope 😉 #989First AND second – that’s just amazing, Janette! I remember your story well – I loved it when I first read it, so deceptively simple yet powerful, without a hint of sentimentality. Just like this one. Very well deserved win, I’m SO happy for you 🙂
-
This reply was modified 8 years, 2 months ago by
KazG.
I’M GOING TO SHOUT TOO! HOORAY!
Such a great story, Sky! I’ve only met you briefly at York (crammed in a car on the way to the railway station with John T and Debi, I think!) but you are obviously such a lovely, humble and kind person – it makes me so happy to see someone like that achieve the success they deserve 🙂 ENJOY!
Congratulations, Helen! You must be buzzing 🙂
Congratulations, Elle, Daeds and Hil 🙂
Er, I have a very little success story to share – my story from the last winter comp run by Ath was long listed for a (small) competition run by a bookstore down here..nothing compared to your successes but it will be in an antho, I believe. So that makes my happy 🙂
wow that’s fantastic news Philippa! Cheering for you from down under 🙂 xx
awww 🙁 I got it too, the white screen of death…a very sad day. Bye bye Cloudling…#farewell
Ath, the comp!! What happens now?
(Why didn’t my clever linky thing to @Jules work??)
And thank you for good wishes Philippa! Getting myself in quite a knot with all the limb crossing over here…Yes I agree about Jessie’s letter being unusually intimate and long winded and having two agents interested allowing that. Definitely. But I did find it interesting that Juliet said she liked a splash of humour and personality in a cover letter as well. But that’s a VERY fine line to tread, between that mere splash and coming over slightly deranged, hmmm?
-
This reply was modified 8 years, 2 months ago by
-
AuthorPosts
